Guide to Choosing the Right RPG System for You

Choosing the Right RPG System for You

Welcome to my comprehensive guide on choosing the perfect RPG system for your gaming group. Whether you’re a seasoned role-playing enthusiast or just starting your gaming journey, selecting the right system is essential for an enjoyable and immersive experience. In this article, I’ll walk you through the key factors to consider and provide recommendations based on your preferences and gameplay style.

Key Takeaways:

  • Consider the desired setting of your RPG game, such as high fantasy, modern world, or sci-fi.
  • Explore different game mechanics, such as turn-based combat or narrative-focused storytelling.
  • Evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of different RPG systems to find the best fit for your group.
  • Consider your players’ preferences and dynamics to ensure everyone enjoys the game.
  • Research popular RPG systems like D&D, Pathfinder, and Dungeon World to make an informed decision.

Understanding Your Desired Setting

When it comes to choosing the right RPG system, one of the first considerations is the setting you want to explore. Different game systems excel in different settings, and understanding your desired setting will help narrow down your options.

If you’re a fan of high fantasy adventures, where dragons roam and magic is abundant, systems like Dungeons and Dragons (D&D) or Pathfinder 2nd Edition are excellent choices. These systems offer rich lore, fantastical creatures, and a wide range of character options to immerse yourself in a world of swords and sorcery.

On the other hand, if you’re more inclined towards modern worlds or futuristic sci-fi settings, there are RPG systems that cater specifically to those preferences. For a modern urban setting, games like Urban Shadows or Monster of the Week can provide a thrilling and supernatural experience. If you’re looking to explore the vastness of space in a sci-fi adventure, systems like Numenera or Starfinder offer exciting possibilities.

RPG SystemRecommended Setting
Dungeons and Dragons (D&D)High Fantasy
Pathfinder 2nd EditionHigh Fantasy
Urban ShadowsModern Urban
Monster of the WeekModern Supernatural

Choosing the right RPG system is all about finding the perfect match for your desired setting. Whether you’re dreaming of epic battles in a high fantasy world or exploring the mysteries of the cosmos in a sci-fi adventure, there is a game system designed to bring your vision to life.

With their magical realms and heroic quests, high fantasy settings are best served by systems like Dungeons and Dragons (D&D) and Pathfinder 2nd Edition. These systems offer a wealth of resources and a vibrant community to support your journey through fantastical worlds.

If you prefer a modern world setting where urban intrigue and supernatural creatures collide, games like Urban Shadows and Monster of the Week provide the perfect backdrop for thrilling adventures. These systems focus on narrative-driven storytelling and offer plenty of flexibility for both players and Game Masters.

For those who crave the wonders of the cosmos and the excitement of futuristic technology, systems like Numenera and Starfinder offer boundless opportunities for sci-fi exploration. Whether you want to delve into ancient alien ruins or engage in intergalactic conflicts, these systems will transport you to worlds beyond imagination.

Exploring Different Game Mechanics

When it comes to RPG systems, understanding the various game mechanics is essential in finding the right fit for your gaming group. Different systems employ different approaches to gameplay, ranging from turn-based combat to immersive storytelling. By exploring these game mechanics, you can determine which system aligns with your preferences and playstyle.

Turn-based game mechanics are a popular choice for many RPG enthusiasts. These systems often incorporate dice rolling and strategic decision-making during combat encounters. Games like Dungeons and Dragons (D&D) are renowned for their turn-based gameplay, offering a structured and tactical experience.

Quote: “Turn-based mechanics in RPG systems provide a sense of strategy and give players time to plan their actions. It adds an element of suspense and allows for collaborative decision-making during combat encounters.” – RPG enthusiast

On the other hand, if you prefer a more narrative-driven experience, systems that emphasize storytelling may be more appealing. These game mechanics prioritize character development, role-playing, and collaborative storytelling. FATE Accelerated, for example, focuses on creating engaging narratives and empowering players to shape the story.

Game MechanicExamples
Turn-basedDungeons and Dragons (D&D), Pathfinder
StorytellingFATE Accelerated, Dungeon World
FlexibilityGURPS, Savage Worlds

Flexibility in-game mechanics is another important aspect to consider. Systems like GURPS (Generic Universal RolePlaying System) and Savage Worlds offer more versatility and adaptability, allowing players to explore a wide range of genres and settings. This flexibility enables Game Masters to create unique and personalized gaming experiences.

By exploring and understanding different game mechanics, you can make an informed decision when choosing an RPG system that aligns with your preferred style of gameplay and storytelling. Whether it’s turn-based combat, immersive storytelling, or versatile flexibility, there’s a system out there that will provide the perfect gaming experience for you and your group.

Evaluating Strengths and Weaknesses

When it comes to choosing the right RPG system for your gaming group, it’s essential to evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of different game systems. Understanding what a system excels in and where it may fall short can help you make an informed decision that aligns with your group’s gameplay and storytelling preferences.

Each RPG system has its own unique strengths that set it apart from others. For example, a system like Dungeons and Dragons (D&D) is known for its rich and immersive high fantasy adventures. It offers a vast array of classes, races, and spells, allowing players to dive into a world of magic and epic quests. On the other hand, systems like FATE Accelerated prioritizes storytelling and role-playing, giving players the freedom to shape the narrative and make impactful choices.

However, no game system is perfect, and it’s crucial to consider the weaknesses as well. For instance, while D&D excels in the high fantasy genre, it may require some tweaking and adaptation to fit other genres like superheroes or horror. It’s important to assess whether the system’s limitations align with your group’s desired gameplay and if you’re willing to put in the work to customize aspects of the game.

“D&D provides an immersive high fantasy experience with a rich setting and endless adventure possibilities. However, it may require some tweaking to fit other genres and has a complex ruleset that may pose a learning curve for some players.”

By evaluating the strengths and weaknesses of different RPG systems, you can determine which system aligns best with your group’s preferences and desired gaming experience. Whether you prioritize deep and intricate combat mechanics or collaborative storytelling, finding a system that suits your group’s needs is key to an enjoyable and engaging tabletop role-playing experience.

Considering Player Preferences

When it comes to choosing the right RPG system, it’s crucial to consider the preferences and dynamics of your gaming group. Each player may have different interests, playstyles, and comfort levels, so finding a system that caters to everyone is key.

Some players thrive in a more rules-intensive environment, where they can dive deep into character customization and tactical combat. A system like GURPS or Shadowrun could be a great fit for them. On the other hand, some players may prefer a more streamlined and narrative-focused experience, emphasizing storytelling and character development. Systems like Dungeon World or FATE Accelerated offer a more accessible and flexible approach.

It’s important to have open discussions with your group and encourage everyone to voice their preferences. This will help you find a balance that works for everyone involved. Remember that the goal is to create an enjoyable and inclusive gaming experience that caters to your players’ diverse interests and playstyles.

Player Preferences

Table: RPG Systems and Player Preferences

RPG SystemPlayer Preference
GURPSRules-intensive gameplay, character customization
ShadowrunTactical combat, cyberpunk setting
Dungeon WorldNarrative focus, streamlined rules
FATE AcceleratedFlexible storytelling, collaborative play

“Understanding and respecting player preferences is essential for a successful RPG campaign. By choosing a system that aligns with their interests, you can create a more engaging and immersive experience for everyone involved.”

Remember, player preferences can evolve over time, so be open to trying new systems or adapting existing ones to suit your group’s changing dynamics. The goal is to create a gaming environment where everyone feels comfortable and excited to participate.

Weighing the Pros and Cons of Popular Systems

When it comes to RPG systems, there are several popular choices that have gained a significant following. Let’s take a closer look at three of the most well-known systems: Dungeons and Dragons (D&D), Pathfinder, and Dungeon World. Each of these systems offers unique features and gameplay styles, catering to different preferences and playstyles.

Dungeons and Dragons (D&D): Known as the granddaddy of RPGs, D&D has been around for decades and has a loyal fan base. It excels at providing a high fantasy experience, with a focus on tactical combat and intricate storytelling. The system offers a vast array of sourcebooks, adventures, and supplements, making it easy for Game Masters to find pre-existing materials or create their own campaigns. However, D&D’s rules can be complex and intimidating for new players, and it may require more preparation and learning time.

Pathfinder: Developed as an offshoot of D&D’s 3.5 edition, Pathfinder offers a more robust and customizable experience. It retains the high fantasy setting but provides additional options, allowing players to create unique characters and explore a vast world. Pathfinder maintains a loyal community and offers a wealth of published adventures and sourcebooks. While it may have a steeper learning curve than D&D, it rewards players with a deep and immersive gameplay experience.

Dungeon World: If you prefer a more narrative-focused and streamlined system, Dungeon World is worth considering. It emphasizes collaborative storytelling and improvisation, allowing players to contribute to the narrative and shape the world together. Dungeon World’s rules are designed to be flexible and easy to learn, making it accessible for beginners. However, some players may find it lacking in tactical depth compared to other systems.

Dungeons and Dragons (D&D)– Vast amount of pre-existing materials
– Intricate storytelling
– Tactical combat
– Complex rules for new players
– Requires more preparation time
Pathfinder– Customizable and robust experience
– Deep and immersive gameplay
– Loyal community
– Steeper learning curve
– Requires more time for character creation
Dungeon World– Emphasis on collaborative storytelling
– Easy to learn for beginners
– Streamlined gameplay
– Lacks tactical depth
– Limited customization options

Choosing the right RPG system ultimately depends on your preferences, the type of gameplay experience you’re looking for, and the dynamics of your gaming group. Consider the strengths and weaknesses of each system and how they align with your desired gaming experience. By weighing the pros and cons, you can make an informed decision and select the system that best suits your needs.

Assessing Crunch, Playability, and GM Lift

When choosing the right RPG system for your gaming group, it’s important to consider three key factors: crunch, playability, and GM lift. These elements play a significant role in determining the overall gaming experience and the level of enjoyment for both players and the Game Master.


Crunch refers to the complexity and depth of the game’s rules and mechanics. Some RPG systems have intricate rulebooks with detailed character creation, combat, and skill resolution systems. These systems can offer a deep and immersive experience but may require more time and effort to learn and master. On the other hand, some systems have simpler and more streamlined rules, allowing for quicker and more intuitive gameplay.

When evaluating the crunch of an RPG system, consider your players’ preferences and comfort levels. If your group enjoys diving into complex mechanics and strategizing in combat, a system with higher crunch, like Pathfinder or GURPS, may be a good fit. However, if your players prefer a more narrative-focused experience with lighter rules, systems like Dungeon World or FATE Accelerated might be more suitable.


Playability refers to how easy and enjoyable the game is for the players. This includes factors such as the clarity of rules, the flow of gameplay, and the overall accessibility of the system. A highly playable RPG system should allow for smooth and engaging gameplay without getting bogged down in complex rules or frequent rule consultations.

When assessing playability, consider the experience level of your players. If you have a group of beginners, a system with a gentle learning curve and clear explanations, like D&D 5th Edition, might be the best choice. Conversely, if your group consists of experienced players who enjoy diving into detailed rulebooks, systems like Shadowrun or Call of Cthulhu may provide the challenge they seek.

GM Lift

GM lift refers to the amount of work and preparation required by the Game Master to run the game effectively. Some RPG systems have extensive worldbuilding requirements, complex encounter creation, and intricate campaign planning. These systems may demand more time and effort from the Game Master, but they can also offer a deeply immersive and rewarding storytelling experience.

Consider the availability and commitment level of your Game Master when evaluating GM lift. If your GM is experienced and enjoys creating intricate worlds and adventures, systems like Legend of the Five Rings or Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay might be a great fit. However, if your GM prefers a more lightweight and improvisational approach, systems like Apocalypse World or Blades in the Dark may be more suitable.

By carefully assessing the crunch, playability, and GM lift of different RPG systems, you can find the perfect fit for your gaming group. Remember to prioritize the preferences and comfort levels of your players, as well as the commitment level and availability of your Game Master. A well-aligned system will enhance the overall gaming experience and create memorable adventures for everyone involved.

CrunchPlayabilityGM Lift
Complex and detailed rulesClear and intuitive gameplayExtensive worldbuilding and planning
Deep and immersive experienceGentle learning curveIntricate encounter creation
High strategy and complexityEasy to understand explanationsImmersive and rewarding storytelling

Exploring Genre-specific Systems

When it comes to RPG systems, there are a variety of options available depending on the genre you want to dive into. Games like Call of Cthulhu offer a thrilling and immersive experience if you’re a fan of horror settings. As you investigate dark mysteries and face unspeakable horrors, the mechanics and atmosphere of these genre-specific systems are designed to enhance the tension and suspense.

On the other hand, if you and your group are more interested in embodying larger-than-life superheroes, RPG systems like Mutants and Masterminds provide the perfect platform for epic battles and heroic adventures. With a robust set of rules allowing for superhuman abilities and dramatic narratives, these genre-specific systems bring the excitement and grandeur of superhero comics to your gaming sessions.

Remember, choosing a genre-specific RPG system ensures that the mechanics, themes, and atmosphere align with the specific genre you want to explore. It immerses players in a world tailored to their interests, making gameplay more engaging and enjoyable. So, whether you’re seeking spine-tingling horror or larger-than-life heroics, there’s a genre-specific RPG system out there waiting to bring your favorite stories to life.

Horror and Superheroes

“The mechanics and atmosphere of these genre-specific systems are designed to enhance the tension and suspense.”

Considering the Group Dynamic

When choosing an RPG system, it’s important to consider the dynamics and preferences of your gaming group. The compatibility between the system and your group can greatly impact your gaming sessions’ overall enjoyment and success. Here are some factors to keep in mind when considering the group dynamic:

Player Preferences:

Take into account the playstyles and preferences of your players. Some may enjoy tactical combat encounters and complex rules, while others may prefer a more narrative-driven experience. It’s important to find a system that caters to your players’ interests and comfort levels to ensure everyone has a good time.

Collaboration and Improvisation:

Consider the level of collaboration and improvisation that your group enjoys. Some systems encourage player agency and collaborative storytelling, allowing players to contribute to the world-building and narrative. Others may have a more structured approach, with the Game Master leading the storytelling. Find a system that aligns with the level of improvisation and collaboration your group desires.

Group Size:

The size of your gaming group can also influence the choice of an RPG system. Some systems work better with smaller groups, offering more opportunities for individual character development and spotlight moments. Other systems excel at accommodating larger groups, ensuring that everyone has a chance to participate and contribute to the story. Consider your group size and choose a system that can effectively accommodate it.

By considering the group dynamic when choosing an RPG system, you can create a more enjoyable and immersive gaming experience for everyone involved. Finding a balance that suits the preferences and playstyle of your players will help foster a positive and engaging atmosphere at the gaming table.

Taking Existing Materials into Account

When selecting an RPG system, one important factor to consider is the availability of existing materials. Some systems offer a wealth of playable adventures, sourcebooks, and supplements that can save you time and effort in preparation. For Game Masters seeking ready-made content, these materials can provide a convenient option.

Systems like Dungeons and Dragons (D&D) and Pathfinder are known for their extensive libraries of published adventures, providing a wide range of options for different settings and campaign styles. These pre-made adventures often come with detailed maps, non-player characters, and plot hooks, allowing the Game Master to focus on running the game rather than creating everything from scratch.

Additionally, having access to existing materials can also benefit players. They can dive into rich lore, explore well-established worlds, and engage with familiar characters and storylines. This can enhance immersion and make it easier for players to connect with the game.

Overall, considering RPG systems with a large selection of playable adventures can be a smart choice if you prefer to utilize pre-existing materials and streamline your game preparation. These materials can provide inspiration, guidance, and convenience, allowing both Game Masters and players to immerse themselves in the game world fully.

The Importance of Player Buy-In

When it comes to choosing the right RPG system for your gaming group, one of the most crucial factors to consider is player buy-in. Player buy-in refers to the level of enthusiasm and agreement among the players regarding the chosen system. It’s important to ensure that everyone feels invested and excited about the game system, as this will contribute to a more enjoyable and cohesive gaming experience.

Engaging in open discussions with your group is key to achieving player buy-in. Take the time to listen to each player’s preferences and concerns, allowing everyone to have a voice in decision-making. This collaborative approach will help you find a system that aligns with the group’s interests and foster a sense of inclusivity and teamwork.

By seeking group consensus, you can avoid situations where some players feel disengaged or disconnected from the game. Everyone on board with the chosen system creates a positive and enthusiastic atmosphere that enhances the overall gaming experience. Remember, RPGs are collaborative storytelling experiences, and player buy-in is essential for bringing the narrative to life.

Benefits of Player Buy-In

  • Increased player satisfaction and engagement.
  • Enhanced group dynamics and collaboration.
  • Greater investment in the game’s story and world.
  • Reduced conflicts or disagreements during gameplay.

Tips for Achieving Player Buy-In

  1. Encourage open and respectful communication within the group.
  2. Consider individual preferences and find a system that caters to everyone’s interests.
  3. Explain the benefits and unique features of the chosen system to generate enthusiasm.
  4. Be willing to compromise and find a middle ground that satisfies the majority of players.

Player buy-in is crucial for a successful RPG campaign. By prioritizing the opinions and preferences of your players, you can create an inclusive and engaging gaming experience that everyone will enjoy. So, take the time to discuss and involve your group in the decision-making process, and watch as the excitement and enthusiasm grow!


In conclusion, choosing the right RPG system is a personal decision that requires careful consideration of various factors. By taking into account your desired setting, preferred game mechanics, and evaluating strengths and weaknesses, you can find a system that aligns with your gameplay style and storytelling preferences.

Remember also to consider the player preferences and group dynamics. Ensuring that everyone in your gaming group is comfortable and engaged is crucial for a successful RPG campaign. Balancing the level of crunch, playability, and GM lift is essential to create an enjoyable gaming experience.

Additionally, genre-specific systems can provide immersive experiences. If you have a specific genre in mind, exploring RPG systems designed for that genre can enhance your gaming sessions. Lastly, consider the availability of existing materials and the importance of player buy-in to facilitate a smooth and enjoyable gaming experience.

With these RPG tips in mind, you can choose the best RPG system for beginners and experienced players. So get ready to embark on epic adventures, create memorable characters, and immerse yourself in the world of tabletop role-playing games!


What factors should I consider when choosing an RPG system?

When choosing an RPG system, it’s important to consider factors like the desired setting, gameplay style, group dynamics, and player preferences.

What are some popular RPG systems?

Some popular RPG systems include Dungeons and Dragons (D&D), Pathfinder, and Savage Worlds.

How do I evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of different game systems?

To evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of different game systems, consider their suitability for particular genres, gameplay styles, and structural preferences.

How do I choose a system that fits my group’s dynamic?

Consider the playstyles, interests, and comfort levels of your players to find an RPG system that fosters a positive and enjoyable group dynamic.

Are there RPG systems tailored for specific genres?

Yes, there are RPG systems designed for specific genres such as horror (Call of Cthulhu) and superheroes (Mutants and Masterminds).

What role do existing materials play in choosing an RPG system?

Some RPG systems offer pre-existing materials like published adventures and sourcebooks, which can be convenient for Game Masters seeking ready-made content.

How important is player buy-in when choosing an RPG system?

Player buy-in and consensus on the chosen system are crucial for a successful RPG campaign. Engage in open discussions with your group to find a system that excites the majority of players.

How can I ensure an enjoyable gaming experience for my group?

By considering factors like setting preferences, gameplay style, and group dynamics, you can choose an RPG system that caters to the interests and enjoyment of your entire gaming group.

Recent Posts